Monsters and Villains: What’s the Difference and When Do I Use Them?

Both villains and monsters are thought about villains, but there are distinctions in between the two. Youll wish to choose which version of villain youre using based on the purpose and tone of your story.

The Main Difference Between Villains and Monsters

Theres extremely little in the way of describing a beasts backstory or stressing over his motivations (because hes attempting to consume you). The focus is on survival for the primary characters and their character arcs in the procedure.

Monsters are, after all, “other” and more unsympathetic. Its simpler for the protagonist to kill a monster.

The Spectrums Middle.

Because beasts have rather simple inspirations, they include a risk to a story and to your main characters. Theres a lot of worry surrounding monsters, so they are a lot more common in scary stories than anywhere else. Not that villains cant inspire worry, but the nature of a monster makes fear a more natural state.

No matter what character youre writing (including B characters!), you must constantly, always comprehend their motivation.

When to Use a Villain.

While Sil does have a supportive background (she was made in a lab and her developers attempted to eliminate her as a child), shes not a supportive character in the tiniest. Shes single-minded and often unnecessarily violent.

Instead of focusing more on survival for your main characters, you can look at morality, wit, devotion to suitables, anything truly.

( A machine can also be an antagonist, by the way, though whether its a monster or a villain depends on how it became. A sentient AI, for example, would be more villain. A rogue robot would be more beast.).

Examples: Hannibal Lecter, Voldemort, Nurse Ratched, Lex Luthor, the Joker, Darth Vader … I think you get the point. Villains are rounded characters with often relatable and/or sympathetic attributes. Theyre capable of communicating without violence and can be thoughtful instead of rash. Theyre complicated.

Examples: Jaws, The Blob, Alien. All of these beasts have the desire to reproduce and/or eat. They are a device in that respect.

On the left side is a pure monster. The right side is a pure bad guy.

Note: Just because beasts have simplified motivation doesnt mean you dont have to put work into their advancement. Have a look at this post on how to create fantastic monsters.

Now lets look at the best side of the spectrum and think about the motivation of the pure bad guy. There is no best answer to the motivation of a villain. A bad guy is (normally) humanoid, and as such has a wealth of backstory, characteristic, and goals/desires. Since of this, a villain is more tough to develop. You need to invest simply as much time considering them as you do your lead character.

When to Use a Monster.

Youve got your pure monster to the left and your pure villain to the. Whats in the middle?

Now lets look at Pennywise, the clown from Stephen Kings It. Hes mainly inhuman in appearance (particularly in the book), compulsively produces fear, and feeding is certainly up there on his priority list. Those are checkmarks for the monster column.

The Monster vs. Villain Spectrum

You most likely believe this is a simple one. “Well, monsters are … monstrous. There can be “monstrous-looking” villains (Two-Face, for instance) and monsters that are humanoid (Sil, gone over later).

Your pure monster on the left has base inspirations, like breeding, feeding, and surviving. Theres no thinking with a monster, as they have no compassion for you.

One more example of someone in the middle: Sil from the motion picture Species. Sil is humanoid (shes alien DNA spliced with human DNA and thought about extremely stunning), yet her motivation is to survive so she can reproduce.

A story using a monster as an antagonist has plenty of space for character advancement for your protagonist. When you desire to put a lot of focus on your main character and their struggles, use a beast.

Sil belongs in the middle, quite near the left/monster side of the spectrum, despite being humanoid in look the majority of the time. See, not every monster is monstrous-looking.

The character arc of your lead character is straight affected by the bad guy, as it is by monsters, but in a more nuanced way. Lead characters can typically be lured by, or understanding towards, villains in a method they cant be with beasts. Character arcs for your primary characters when up against a villain are also more fascinating.

But he likewise loathes the band of good friends, has the ability to interact without being violent, and vengeance plays a huge part in his inspiration to intimidate the primary characters. Those are villainous qualities. Pennywise goes in the middle of the spectrum as a good mix of bad guy and monster.

The most typical character arc here is the primary character going from “weak” to “strong” in order to beat the beast.

His inspirations consist of feeding, but thats not the only thing he wants. Hes a complicated mix of beast and bad guy, so he goes in the middle.

Villains bring stress to your story. Like beasts, they can also bring fear, however since their inspirations are more cerebral and they tend to look human, pure worry is less typical.

You most likely think about motivation with your lead character, however do you do it with your antagonist? Otherwise, your villain is uninteresting and flat.

The crucial difference in between villains and monsters: motivation. What does your protagonists enemy want?

The primary distinction between bad guys and monsters is pretty simple: all of it comes down to inspiration.

Whats the Purpose of Your Story?

The function is where you need to begin with every story. In other words, whats your storys motivation?

Are you desiring your main character to battle with their own morality? Do you desire to develop a really kickass creature to let loose on a town?

What if its a bit of all of the above? Develop a monstrous villain or a villainous monster!

Pick whether you want to develop a villain or a beast. (If youre going for monster, absolutely inspect out this post on structure great beasts.

Sarah Gribble.

Consider Frankensteins monster. Where do you think he falls on the Monster vs. Villain Spectrum? Let me know in the remarks!

When youre done, share your writing in the comments. Dont forget to talk about your fellow authors work!

Your antagonist in every scenario is there to serve your story. Believe about how you want them to serve your story, and the finest way to have them do so, prior to you begin writing and youll be well on your way to developing an incredible story!

Sarah Gribble is the author of lots of short stories that explore uneasy circumstances, standard worries, and the general wonder and fascination of the unknown. She simply released.
Enduring Death, her very first novel, and is currently dealing with her next book.
Follow her on Instagram or join her email list free of charge scares.

Then, set a timer for fifteen minutes. Develop your monster or bad guy. DONT FORGET THE MOTIVATION!

The character arc of your lead character is straight affected by the bad guy, as it is by monsters, but in a more nuanced way. Select whether you desire to develop a monster or a villain. (If youre going for beast, absolutely check out this post on building terrific beasts.


( A machine can likewise be a villain, by the method, though whether its a beast or a villain depends on how it came to be. Pennywise goes in the middle of the spectrum as a nice mix of villain and beast.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *